Before you proceed, there are spoilers.
Joker: Folie à Deux is as a provocative exploration of mental illness and identity, set against a backdrop that intertwines the fantastical elements of comic book lore with stark realities. In this sequel to the 2019 film Joker, director Todd Phillips extends Arthur Fleck’s (Joaquin Phoenix) harrowing journey as he transitions from a tragic figure to a chaotic antihero. By embracing surreal musical elements and intense character traits, Folie à Deux delivers a story that taps into contemporary conversations particularly around mental health.
The film opens with Arthur imprisoned in Arkham State Hospital, grappling with the consequences of his actions while awaiting trial for the murders he committed in the first film. This setting is significant; it reflects the stigmatization and marginalization of individuals dealing with mental health issues. Just as Arkham’s walls confine Arthur, many people with mental illnesses often face isolation, battling societal perceptions that label them as dangerous or untrustworthy.The courtroom drama element showcases how society judges those who diverge from normative behavior, casting a critical eye on the legal and social systems that fail to understand the complexities of mental health.
As the narrative unfolds, Arthur encounters Harley Quinn (Lady Gaga), a fellow patient whose obsession with him fuels both their relationship and their collective descent into madness. Their bond, characterized by chaos and manipulation, illustrates the often toxic nuances that can emerge from shared mental illness. In reality, relationships between individuals facing mental health challenges can be deeply complicated. The film encapsulates this complexity, showing how love and obsession can become intertwined, leading to further instability. Harley’s infatuation with the Joker persona rather than Arthur Fleck reveals the tendency for people to idolize those who embody chaotic traits, mirroring society’s fascination with antiheroes and celebrity culture.
Moreover, Folie à Deux utilizes musical sequences to depict Arthur’s dissociative experiences. These surreal moments serve as a powerful juxtaposition against the trauma and violence of their reality. The musical elements reflect how art and creativity can both mask and reveal pain. Many individuals struggling with mental illness may turn to music, art, or performance as a means of expression or escape. The film’s portrayal of Arthur’s and Harley’s chaotic performances resonates with the way people often seek solace in creative outlets while simultaneously grappling with their demons.
The film’s narrative structure, with its disjointed musical sequences and nonlinear progression, mirrors the fragmented nature of Arthur’s psyche. This representation aligns with the experiences of many individuals facing emotions that are difficult to articulate or connect coherently. Throughout the film, the disconnect between Arthur’s Joker identity and his real self becomes increasingly apparent. The psychological fragmentation depicted in Folie à Deux resonates with the real-life experiences of dissociation.
Despite its artistic ambition, the film has received criticism for its narrative coherence. People argue that the musical elements detract from the gravity of Arthur’s story, making it feel less grounded. However, this disjointedness can also be viewed as a reflection of the chaotic nature of mental illness itself. Just as individuals experiencing severe psychological distress may struggle to maintain a coherent narrative in their lives, the film captures this struggle through its structure and character development.
While the film digs deep into the darker aspects of Arthur’s transformation into the Joker, it also critiques society’s role in shaping the narrative of mental illness.The film portrays Arthur’s violent acts as a product of his circumstances, showing how societal neglect, stigma, and lack of understanding push individuals toward extreme behavior.
This critique amplifies real-world discussions about the importance of mental health awareness, access to care, and the dangers of reducing complex individuals to mere labels of “madness” or “violence.”
The film’s conclusion hints at a deeper narrative twist: the suggestion that Arthur may not be the true Joker but rather a precursor to a more sinister version. This introduces the idea that Arthur’s madness is not an isolated phenomenon but rather a symptom of a larger societal issue, demonstrating how society creates and perpetuates figures like Joker. This raises important questions about the systems in place that contribute to the marginalization and criminalization of individuals with mental health issues, urging audiences to consider their complicity in these narratives.
@jokermovie Discover Lee. Joker: Folie à Deux – only in theaters and @imax tomorrow. Get tickets now. Link in bio. #JokerMovie #FilmedForIMAX
Joaquin Phoenix delivers a haunting and fragile performance as Arthur Fleck, juxtaposing his quiet vulnerability with the explosive nature of his Joker persona. Lady Gaga brings an unhinged intensity to her portrayal of Harley Quinn. Her representation contrasts with Margot Robbie’s more playful version, embodying a darker, more obsessive energy. Together, their broken characters drive the film, offering a slow-burning, soulful experience that transcends typical comic book movies and presents a more humanized and original take on the Joker’s character.
Critics have labeled the movie as narratively and aesthetically incoherent, yet its musical nature allows for a certain level of disjointedness. The performances by Phoenix and Gaga stand out, particularly in scenes where their singing contrasts with their vulnerable realities. One standout moment features the song “The Joker,” encapsulating Arthur’s internal struggle. He never wanted to become the Joker, but it’s the only identity that garners him the acceptance he craves.
The ending cleverly hints that Phoenix’s Joker may not be the one destined to confront Batman. In a brilliant twist, the “real” Joker is introduced, with Arthur paving the way for his darker counterpart. In the end, Joker: Folie à Deux serves as a poignant commentary on the complexities of mental illness and the human experience. While it may polarize audiences, its boldness in tackling uncomfortable themes and its artistic ambition make it a film worth discussing. If we had to score it, Joker: Folie à Deux earns a solid 7/10. It’s not for everyone.
